ULTIMATE HARDWARE

RADEON 9200 vs GEFORCE5200 REVIEW

"ATI Radeon 9200 is based on the RV280 VPU which is a minor revision of the RV250 VPU. What this means is that the ATI Radeon 9200 is the ATI Radeon 9000 with AGP 8X support. The ATI Radeon 9200 unlike the Nvidia GeForce5200 doesn't have support for DirectX9. The Nvidia GeForce5200 is the ATI Radeon 9200's main competitor and because it is a member of the GeForce family it has support for CineFX engine and support for DirectX9 including the latest Pixel and Vertex Shaders."
RADEON 9200 vs GEFORCE5200


GENERAL SYSTEM INFORMATION

VIDEO CARD ATI RADEON 9200
NVIDIA GEFORCE 5200
PROCESSOR AMD ATHLON XP 2500
MOTHERBOARD ASROCK K7S8X
MEMORY 512MB CRUCIAL PC2700 DDR
OPERATING SYSTEM WINDOWS XP SERVICE PACK 1
DIRECTX VERSION v9.0A


QUAKE III ARENA

800x600

ATI RADEON 9200194
NVIDIA GEFORCE5200212

1024x768

ATI RADEON 9200135
NVIDIA GEFORCE5200159

1280x1024

ATI RADEON 9200111
NVIDIA GEFORCE5200132

ATI RADEON 9200 NVIDIA GEFORCE5200

COMMENT - "Nvidia has always had excellent OpenGL support so it was no surprise that the GeForce5200 outperformed the Radeon 9200 by 13%."

SERIOUS SAM
SECOND ENCOUNTER

800x600

ATI RADEON 9200157
NVIDIA GEFORCE5200160

1024x768

ATI RADEON 9200120
NVIDIA GEFORCE5200129

1280x1024

ATI RADEON 920094
NVIDIA GEFORCE520099

ATI RADEON 9200 NVIDIA GEFORCE5200

COMMENT - "The performance difference between the Radeon 9200 and GeForce5200 is much closer with Serious Sam. However the GeForce5200 is still able to outperform the Radeon 9200 by 7%."

UNREAL TOURNAMENT 2003

800x600

ATI RADEON 920077
NVIDIA GEFORCE520096

1024x768

ATI RADEON 920051
NVIDIA GEFORCE520064

1280x1024

ATI RADEON 920035
NVIDIA GEFORCE520043

ATI RADEON 9200 NVIDIA GEFORCE5200

COMMENT - "The large performance difference between the GeForce5200 and Radeon 9200 is almost shocking. The GeForce5200 outperforms the Radeon 9200 by a VERY IMPRESSIVE 21%."

CONCLUSION - "The GeForce5200 delivered a big performance advantage over the Radeon 9200 with almost all of the software we used. The Radeon 9200 isn't a slow video card because it delivered performance which was very playable but the GeForce5200 was just faster. Another advantage the GeForce5200 has over the Radeon 9200 is Directx9 support which should make it more future proof. The only worry is that both of the video cards performed badly with the 3dmark 2003 game benchmarks Battle of Proxycon and Troll's Lair. Even though the GeForce5200 was the only video card featured which could use the DX9 Mother Nature test it was far too slow and if it was a game it would be totally unplayable."

RADEON 9200 vs GEFORCE520

PAGE 1 - RADEON 9200 vs GEFORCE520 INTRODUCTION
PAGE 2 - 3DMARK 2001 SE TO 3DMARK 2003
PAGE 3 - QUAKE III ARENA, SERIOUS SAM SE AND UNREAL TOURNAMENT 2003

HOME = CPU - MOTHERBOARD - NEWS - 3D BENCH - SITEMAP - TECH - VIDEO CARD - BYTE NEWS - BLOG - LINKS

COPYRIGHT © 2012 SEO101UK ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

I hope you enjoy my reviews on ati video cards, be sure to use this information when picking out a new ati video card that's right for your computing needs

LATEST REVIEWS

HIS RADEON HD 7950
AMD A6 3650 VS ATHLON X3 455
ASUS RADEON HD 7970
AMD PHENOM II X4 960T
SAPPHIRE RADEON HD 7970
AMD A6 3650 VS AMD A8 3850
AMD A8 3850 VS ATHLON X3 455
INTEL CORE i5 2500 VS FX 8150
AMD FX 8150 VS X6 1100T
PHENOM II X6 1100T VS i5 2500K
INTEL CORE i3 2100 VS CORE i3 530
INTEL CORE i3 530 VS AMD X3 455
INTEL CORE i3 2100 VS AMD X3 455
CORE i5 2500K VS PHENOM II 970
AMD PHENOM II X4 970 VS X4 955
AMD ATHLON II X3 455 VS X4 620
AMD ATHLON II X3 455 VS X2 560
AMD ATHLON II X3 455 VS X2 265
AMD ATHLON II X3 455
AMD ATHLON II X3 435
AMD PHENOM II X2 560 VS X4 645
AMD PHENOM II X2 560 VS X4 955
CORE i3 2120 VS PHENOM II 955
CORE i3 2120 VS PHENOM II 560
INTEL CORE i3 2120
AMD ATHLON II X4 620
AMD PHENOM II X4 955
AMD PHENOM II X2 560
SAPPHIRE RADEON HD 6850
SAPPHIRE RADEON HD 6770
HIS RADEON HD 6850
PALIT GEFORCE GTX 460 SONIC
POWERCOLOR RADEON 6790
AMD ATHLON II X2 265
POWERCOLOR RADEON 5770
PALIT GEFORCE GTX 550
PALIT GEFORCE GTX 560
AMD ATHLON II X4 645
AMD ATHLON II X2 255
PALIT GEFORCE GTS 450 SONIC
PALIT GEFORCE GTS 450
SAPPHIRE RADEON HD 6970
MSI GEFORCE GTX 570
ZOTAC GEFORCE GTX 580
SAPPHIRE RADEON HD 6870